The Pros + Cons of Different Roof Types
This article is brought to you by RonOvations, one of the renowned roofing companies in Manitoba.
The roof has both protective and aesthetic functions. From the classic charm of shingles to the sleek look of flat roofs, you have many options and styles to choose from. However, don't forget that it isn't all about the style; each roof type has its advantages and downsides. Homeowners who are planning roof replacement should understand these matters to make an informed decision.
We bring a comprehensive guide covering the pros and cons of each roof type.
ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOFS
Pros:
Affordability: Asphalt shingles are affordable; the final cost depends on the material and roof size. The average price for shingle roof installation in Canada is $4,750.
Easy repairing: Damaged shingles can be replaced individually.
Different colors and styles: Shingles are available in various styles so that you can find the perfect match for your architectural style.
Cons:
Shorter lifespan: Depending on the weather and maintenance, they last between 15 to 30 years.
Maintenance: Shingles require frequent inspections, debris removal, algae and moss treatment, and replacements.
Susceptible to weather damage: High-speed winds can blow off shingles, and hail can break them.
METAL ROOFS
Pros:
Long lasting: They can last 40 to 70 years, which is longer when compared to other materials.
Durability: Can withstand extreme weather conditions.
No maintenance: Homeowners can save time since metal roofs don't need maintenance.
Energy efficiency: Absorbs the heat and keeps the home cool, which reduces utility bills.
Cons:
High costs: On average, installing a metal roof costs $6.00 – $8.00 per square foot. Steel is the cheapest material, while copper is the most expensive.
Noisy: you might not like the sound of rain and hail hitting the roof.
Look: It might not fit some architectural styles or preferences.
STONE-COATED METAL ROOFS
Pros:
Durability: Can withstand high winds, heavy rainfall, and hailstorms.
Longevity: with a lifespan ranging from 40 to 70 years, it provides homeowners peace of mind.
Style: Provides aesthetic appeal to traditional shingles, available in various colors.
Energy efficiency: reflects the heat away from your home, saving electricity.
Cons:
High costs: $8 to $18 per square foot on average.
Complex installation: Requires special training to work with a reputable contractor with expertise in this material.
Denting: Large objects can cause dents.
WOODEN SHINGLES
Pros:
Affordable: The average cost is $6.53–$9.90 per square foot.
Easy to repair: Individual shingles can be replaced.
Natural look: The natural wood grain texture is a sought-after aesthetic that complements many styles.
Cons:
Shorter lifespan: Cedar roof lasts about 30 years.
Frequent maintenance: Requires protective treatments periodically.
Damage: Susceptible to rusting, mold, and insect infestation.
FLAT ROOFING
Pros:
Adorable: Requires less materials and labor.
Rooftop garden: Create an outdoor entertainment area, perfect for houses with small yards.
Simple maintenance: Accessibility makes maintenance easier.
Aesthetic: Desired features in modern houses.
Cons:
Drainage issues: This requires thoughtful design and a well-executed drainage system.
Maintenance: Removing debris, inspecting the sealant, and repairing damage should be done frequently.
Less living space: There is no attic or loft in the house.
AESTHETIC ASPECT
What about the aesthetic? We understand you might want a flat roof for that ultramodern look, but it might not be ideal for any style. Asphalt shingles are a versatile solution that fits both contemporary and traditional houses.
Are you looking for a sleek solution with clean lines? Metal roofs are ideal for mid-century and contemporary homes. You might not like the sound of hail bumping against the metal, but we're talking about looks here. Rest assured, it will fit your minimalist building with its refined feel.
Are you looking for an option that is as charming as asphalt shingles but durable? Stone-coated metal roofs bring longevity without sacrificing good looks. With a stone grain coating, they mimic the look of traditional shingles.
Do you want to achieve a natural feel? Look no further than wood roofs. The organic wood texture adds to the curb appeal.
Once you have chosen your roof, it is time to pair it with the siding. Always use the same color tones for the roof and siding. If you select a cool gray metal roof, stick with cool off-white or light gray.
With so many roofing types, it all comes down to the architectural style, your needs, budget, durability, and maintenance. Stone-coated metal roofs are an investment for peace of mind, while flat roofs have a modern vibe. Metal roofs require close to no maintenance but require a significant initial investment.
This article is brought to you by RonOvations, one of the renowned roofing companies in Manitoba.
FURTHER READING
